Attention: the information about this menu is outdated (updated more than a month ago).

Menu for Mousetrap Bar & Grill


Country & region

Indianapolis, Indiana, USA


5565 N Keystone Ave

Postal Code


The Shining Star

Indys biggest & best tenderloin. 8 oz. fresh hand patted tenderloin breaded or grilled.

Uncle Johns Stew

Hungarian style beef stew with cabbage, carrots, potatoes, onions & peppers.

The Greatest Chili Ever Sold

Grandma Reillys chili was voted #1. in Indy! Add-ons for an additional charge.

China Cat Chicken Salad

Kandas famous recipe served on your choice of bread or over tomatoes & lettuce.

Birdsongs Wings

8 huge hot wings.

Fire on a Mountain of Chips

Housemade fresh salsa and chips made to order.

Crazy Fingers

Fried portobella mushroom fingers with horsey sauce.

Franklins Tenders

Hand battered chicken tenders with your choice of dip.

They Loin Each Other

Huge tenderloin strips, breaded, fried, served with horsey sauce and meant to be shared.

Potato Tots Caboose

Add-ons for an additional charge.

Fries Caboose

Add-ons for an additional charge.

A Simple Twist of Dough

Super soft pretzel style breadsticks served with whole grain mustard and cheese sauce.

Wicked Felinas Quesadilla

Our veggie quesadilla is legendary! Add meat for an additional charge.

#1. Italian Salad

Back to back chicken shacks or substitute a portobello. Grilled chicken with artichokes, tomatoes, Parmesan & red onions with basil vinaigrette.

#2. Southwest Salad

Back to back chicken shacks or substitute a portobello. Grilled chicken with cheddar, corn & black bean salsa, tomato & onion with homemade ranch.

I Need a Vegetable Salad

Mixed greens, carrots, cucumber, tomato, red onion and croutons with choice of dressing.

The Shining Star

Yep, here it is again. Our signature 8 oz. hand breaded or grilled tenderloin made to order.

Mr. Charlie

A grilled 8 oz. tenderloin with ham, Swiss, bacon and a Dijon cream sauce.

Hard to Handle

Po boy style. Grilled or breaded with Creole slaw, tomatoes, pickles & a spicy remoulade.

Stone Jack Balle

8 oz. tenderloin blackened in Cajun spices, grilled & served with lettuce, tomato, onion & chipotle mayo.

Smokestack Lightning

Grilled or breaded. We top this one with our hot pepper stew and pepper jack cheese.

Big Steves Fatty Melt

Between 2 grilled cheese sandwiches with lots of crispy bacon.

San Francisco Melt

On a back porch in july. Grilled onions, Swiss and our homemade dressing on sourdough bread.

Big Easy Wind Burger

Cajun seasoned patty with red onion, pepper jack cheese and chipotle mayo.

Big Boss Man Burger

Bacon, BBQ sauce, cheddar, fried pickles, grilled onion, onion rings & ranch.

Steal Your Sandwich

Special sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickles & onions. Sound Familiar?

Build to Last Burger

BYO burger. Add toppings of your choice.

Blackened Stella Blue Burger

Blackened patty with bacon, onion rings and blue cheese crumbles & dressing.

Jerrys Jam Burger

Tomato bacon jam, whiskey onions and pepper jack cheese.

Deep Elem BLT Sandwich

Made the old fashion way with crispy Indiana flat bacon on your choice of bread.

Reuben Sandwich

Hot corned beef, Swiss and sauerkraut, scrambled with 1000 Island on rye.

Cherise Sandwich

Hot turkey, Swiss and sauerkraut, scrambled with 1000 Island on rye.

Turkey Melt Your Face Sandwich

Turkey, cheddar & roasted tomatoes with basil mayo. Perfectly pressed on sourdough!

Veggie Melt Your Face

Mushrooms, artichoke hearts, cucumber, tomato, sauteed onion, Swiss, cheddar & basil mayo.

Grilled Phil, Bob and Jerry Sandwich

Pb&J. Peanut butter & grape jelly all buttered up & grilled on Texas toast. Add or substitute Billy (banana) or Mickey (marshmallow).

Beef it on Down the Line Sandwich

Roast beef, cheddar, bacon & red onions with horseradish sauce on a hoagie roll.

Willys in 4 Cheese Drive Sandwich

Cheddar, American, pepper jack & Swiss, double stacked, grilled and quartered.

Duprees Hot-Pressed Italian Sandwich

Ham, salami, pepperoni, pepper jack cheese, banana peppers & roasted tomato with basil mayo.

The Magic Mushroom Sandwich

A portobello mushroom served your way. Grilled to perfection!

Uncle Sams Ham & Cheese Sandwich

A pile of hot ham with melted mozzarella or your choice of cheese, steamed and served on a toasted bun.

Pepperoni Half Step and Sausage Too-Deloo Pizza

Classic sausage and pepperoni. Feel free to add more toppings for an additional charge.

The Corrina Pizza

Marinated chicken, roasted tomatoes, artichoke hearts, red onion, mozzarella, Parmesan & olive oil.

Althea Margherita Pizza

Sliced tomato, olive oil, mozzarella, fresh basil and spices.

I Need a Vegetable Pizza

Marinara sauce with portobellos, spinach, tomato, onion, green pepper, basil and garlic.

Dont Feel Like a Stranger Pizza

Feel free to build your own. Start with sauce & cheese.

Choose region


Point on map

We use cookies to provide necessary website functionality and improve your experience. By using our website, you agree to our legal policies: rules